
Dan Wyke
Dan Wyke – a counsellor and person with M.E. – answers some questions about his experiences as both a therapist and a chronically ill person.
(Seeing Dan on twitter advocating for people with M.E. and discussing his experiences as a therapist with the condition is one of the things that inspired this website.)
What prompted your interest in counselling or therapy with people who have long-term health conditions?
Before I became a counsellor I worked for Age UK where I regularly came into contact with people experiencing problems with their health. Sometimes there wasn’t a service I could direct them to but I was able to give them time to talk about how their health difficulties were affecting their lives. I saw how much they valued this and decided to attend some training to develop my listening skills.
A few years after I qualified as a counsellor, I developed ME/CFS and quickly became aware that most patients, although seriously ill, don’t feel understood or even believed by their GP. Worse still, the year after I qualified, The Lancet published the highly flawed PACE Trial which ultimately led to NICE recommending graded exercise therapy (GET) – even though exercise is potentially harmful to patients suffering from Post-exertional malaise (PEM) – and cognitive behaviour therapy (CBT) – to cure patients, the researchers claimed, of the “unhelpful beliefs” which perpetuate patients’ symptoms.
Through my own experience of ME/CFS I already understood the risks associated with trying to increase physical activity, and I felt troubled by the idea of CBT being manipulated by some practitioners, it seemed, to gaslight clients/patients. I was coming into contact with more people on social media who felt let down and traumatised by their interactions with Health & Social Care professionals, and it wasn’t long after that I started to receive inquiries from ME/CFS patients about counselling support.
What is your experience, as a chronically ill person yourself, within the therapy profession?
I’m sorry to say I’ve encountered disbelief and non-evidence-based opinions about ME/CFS from other counsellors, both as a client and a colleague. Because the psycho-social paradigm of ME/CFS is so embedded in the health service, and because media-generated stigmatising of patients is so ingrained in the public imagination, counsellors are just as likely as anyone else to minimise the seriousness of the disease or hold outdated and harmful views about the disease’s pathophysiology and how to treat it.
Furthermore, given the inevitable propensity for many counsellors to view experience exclusively through the prism of psychology, many still adhere to the cognitive-behavioural model of causation despite an overwhelming amount of biomedical research evidence contradicting this view; and still harbour the belief it can be cured by psychotherapeutic interventions.
Otherwise perfectly competent counsellors can be surprisingly dogmatic about what they think contributes to good health or assists in the management of most physical health conditions, even when they don’t have any relevant medical training to back this up. But these ideas just don’t apply to ME/CFS and will very quickly alienate clients who have ME/CFS. If a counsellor is going to develop a genuinely therapeutic relationship with a client with ME/CFS, they need to weed out thinking that they know what’s best for their client and undertake to learn everything they know about the condition from them. For some reason people are very attached to ideas about health and they can be extremely hard to uproot. That’s partly why a specialist directory of counsellors is needed.
Since the COVID-19 pandemic started, an increase in the number of people meeting diagnostic criteria for ME/CFS has brought about some improvement in attitudes towards infection-associated chronic illness among counsellors – not least because many have been affected themselves. Even so there’s still a tendency among counsellors to practice beyond their medical competence and misguidedly recommend treatments which are from the the wellness industry and aren’t supported by research.
What’s needed is a major effort by the profession’s regulatory bodies, like the BACP, to ensure members aren’t practicing outside of their competency and are aware of the updated NICE guidelines which explicitly state GET should not be offered as a treatment for ME/CFS and CBT should only be offered to patients who want it to help them adapt to living with a life-changing medical condition.
What issues do you find people with long term health problems present with?
People with ME/CFS contact me for all sorts of reasons but all of them have experienced disbelief and gaslighting by a health professional at some point in their illness. Sometimes years, and in some cases, decades of disbelief has left them doubting their own experience. They want to be believed and to feel validated. The harm caused by gaslighting by medical professionals is real and profound. It’s immensely hard for patients to live in a world that doesn’t want to acknowledge the reality of individuals’ illness and suffering. Not only can it lead to dangerous neglect but it can also cause patients to question their own sense of reality. Clients describe it as a form of mental torture.
Clients might also be struggling with disbelief or abuse from their families or a partner or spouse. They might be navigating a change in the severity of their illness and want to talk through how this is affecting their mental health. Clients have typically lost a lot of their lives to illness so there’s often the need to talk about that and if necessary grieve for the lives which haven’t been lived. Clients sometimes also feel like they’ve been through things that other people wouldn’t understand. It’s vital for them to connect with someone who tries, at least, to understand that. It’s also not uncommon for clients to want to talk about despair and the thoughts they’re having about ending their own life.
What training have you been offered around issues to do with long term health? And has this training been relevant and useful?
There’s very little training available for counsellors on working with chronic illness. It’s something I would like to develop if I was well enough to take on the task. I’m aware that counsellors working within the NHS can attend a training module about long-term health conditions but I can’t vouch for its accuracy. It’s definitely an area where more work needs to be done.
What kinds of experiences do people with chronic ill health struggle with in terms of their relationships with carers and healthcare professionals?
As mentioned above, clients who have ME/CFS often struggle to be believed or understood by their health professionals and carers. GPs still emerge from training without having learnt anything about infection-associated chronic illness despite its widespread prevalence since the pandemic and despite the fact patients have been presenting at GP surgeries with these conditions for decades. Needless to say this leads to patients being neglected, forcing them to turn to unproven and expensive treatments.
What advice would you give to people considering therapy if they have a long-term health condition? What questions could they ask a therapist to gauge their attitudes and level of knowledge?
It’s always a good idea to request a preliminary session with a prospective counsellor to gauge whether they’re the right fit for you. People managing long-term health conditions will likely have specific concerns. Clients might want to ask the counsellor if they’re familiar with the updated NICE guidelines on the diagnosis and treatment of ME/CFS. They might want to check if the counsellor knows that GET is potentially harmful to people with ME/CFS and that CBT should only be used to help manage the effects of living with ME/CFS.
Then there might be practical considerations.
- Does the counsellor offer phone sessions (so clients can lie down comfortably during the session without the exertion required to concentrate on a screen)?
- Does the counsellor offer shorter sessions? If so, how are these charged?
- What’s the counsellor’s cancellation policy?
- Does the counsellor understand that clients can’t always tell if they’re well enough to keep an appointment until the day of the appointment?
Counsellors with experience of working with people with ME/CFS should be happy to discuss these points and willing to make any necessary adjustments.
What do you hear from clients about their experience of therapists who don’t have a good understanding of chronic illness? How do they broach it with you? How do you broach it with them?
Some clients come to me having had a negative experience with another counsellor. Typically this takes the form of the client feeling like the counsellor doesn’t really get the physical challenges faced by patients, or the mental and emotional distress caused by gaslighting and neglect. In some cases counsellors have also suggested harmful or unproven treatments. It’s important that they feel able to express their disappointment and frustration without fear of being rejected. Ultimately clients shouldn’t feel obliged to remain in a substandard counselling relationship.
Photo credit: Thanks to RedCharlie an Unsplash for the photo at the top of this post and to Dan Wyke for his portrait.

